Traditional owners claim Bravus breaking emissions laws

Lawyers have written to Queensland environment minister Leanne Linard asking for an investigation into whether the Carmichael coalmine is complying with its environmental conditions.

Aug 09, 2023, updated May 22, 2025
Tribal leader Adrian Burragubba speaks during a rally at Queensland Parliament in Brisbane, Monday, August 30, 2021. The Queensland government is being urged to intervene to ensure Bravus' controversial coal mine project is not draining a nearby nationally significant wetland. (AAP Image/Russell Freeman) NO ARCHIVING
Tribal leader Adrian Burragubba speaks during a rally at Queensland Parliament in Brisbane, Monday, August 30, 2021. The Queensland government is being urged to intervene to ensure Bravus' controversial coal mine project is not draining a nearby nationally significant wetland. (AAP Image/Russell Freeman) NO ARCHIVING

Special Counsel Alison Rose is representing Adrian Burragubba, Gurridyula (Coedie) McAvoy and the Nagana Yarrbayn Cultural Custodians, members of the Wangan and Jagalingou nation.

Mr Burragubba and his son Mr McAvoy have been fighting against mining operations by Indian company Adani and its Australian subsidiary Bravus for more than a decade.

Advertisement

The Carmichael mine is 160 kilomtres north west of Clermont in central Queensland.

The first stage of the mine is producing in the order of 10 million tonnes of coal per year, all for export.

Mr McAvoy has been camping at Waddananggu, living in the shadow of the Carmichael coalmine for almost two years and has previously complained to the state’s Department of Environment and Science about the mine’s operations.

Ms Rose said her clients are concerned that Bravus is committing an offence under the Environmental Protection Act by allegedly failing to comply with noise and dust emission controls for a ā€˜sensitive place’.

ā€œOur clients have made some complaints already and there hasn’t been any investigation of their complaint, any response from Adani or any monitoring of noise or dust on site at all as a response to those complaints,ā€ she said.

ā€œSo essentially, they appear to have been ignored.ā€

Ms Rose said the emissions are an unreasonable limitation of her clients’ cultural rights protected by the Queensland Human Rights Act.

ā€œFirst Nations should be able to peacefully practise their culture on their country without unreasonable interference, that’s a really important principle,ā€ she said.

ā€œIt’s up to the regulator to enforce the noise and dust limits to prevent unreasonable interference with their cultural practices.ā€

Nagana Yarrbayn Cultural Custodians have been on the mine site and are presently conducting cultural ceremonies on Ngarra (North) Waddananggu, including to strengthen relationships with the land and conserve and protect the land.

Stay informed, daily

Mr Burragubba told AAP that his people belong to the land of his ancestors.

ā€œWe connect with that land and we take our people out there so we can teach our young people about their totems and their connection to their land,ā€ he said.

Bravus has campaigned against Mr Burragubba and Mr McAvoy, claiming the ā€œunauthorised protest camp on our mining lease was organised and bankrolled by the anti-fossil fuel lobbyā€.

Advertisement

The company has also alleged Mr McAvoy assaulted a company employee and started an ā€œillegal bushfireā€.

ā€œThere’s no protest because we’ve already been granted these rights,ā€ Mr Burragubba said.

ā€œAnd any time anybody, a private individual, a company, anybody is limiting those human rights, we can ask the government to intervene, so this is where we are today.ā€

Mr McAvoy denies assaulting anyone and posted a video explaining how cultural burning protects country and helps animals.

ā€œIt’s really hard to try and live around that area because of the noise and dust that’s coming off from the pit straight across the road from us,ā€ he said.

ā€œAt night time you shine a torch up into the air and you just see it’s just filled with dust. Everyone’s starting to cough.ā€

Mr McAvoy said people, animals and plants were being affected by large amounts of dust.

ā€œThe noise as well, because it keeps it keeps us all up,ā€ he said.

ā€œWe can hear the morning birds going in the middle of the night, because they think that it’s morning, so it’s messing up the balance with the birds.ā€

Questions have been sent to both Bravus and Ms Linard.

Want to see more stories from InDaily Qld in your Google search results?

  1. Click here to set InDaily Qld as a preferred source.
  2. Tick the box next to "InDaily Qld". That's it.
    Advertisement
    Archive
    Advertisement